Ladies and gentlemen, your top 12 ...

Previous | | Next

11 March 2010 @ 08:59 pm

Ladies and gentlemen, your top 12 ...

The results are in ...

Obviously, I'm bummed, but more than that I really am shocked. I really, really did not see Katelyn going. Especially over some of those who stayed. Wow. Well, I'm glad that at least I switched my #1 back to Crystal. *sigh* With that said, as much as I love Crystal, I'm worried about her. She does NOT look like she's doing well. Todrick going was a given. I'm not shocked that Alex went over Andrew, but I am a little surprised because I thought Alex seemed to have more of a fanbase. But Crystal is safe, Tim's safe (woohoo!), Didi and Lacey are safe, and I like those four, so that's something. They were the four out of the five I wanted to see move on.

You know what else is something? The best part of the entire evening (sorry Crystal, Tim, Didi and Lacey)?!!?

LILY IS GONE!!!!!

I don't care if Katie sucked royal monkey balls with that song, I will GLADLY take her over Lily Scott. I'm so sorry about Katelyn, but thrilled that I don't have to deal with that self-indulgent, fakey fake mcfakerson any longer! YES!

ETA: After Katelyn sang and the girls were hugging her, you can clearly see Crystal say "that's fucked up." I agree, Crystal, I agree.

Tags: american idol, tv

6 comments | Sharing is Caring

6 comments —

( 6 comments — Sharing is Caring )

chessarook on March 12th, 2010 02:27 am (UTC)

I thought Lily has an interesting quality but not necessarily routing her.I've been routing for Crystal from day one for girls so glad she's staying. I was disappointed Alex got kicked off though! I was sold as rooting for him after last week with his 70's mullet and Sheldon-like plaid suit jacket.

I still like Tim,Crystal,Siobhan & Lee. I was surprised at Katelyn! SERIOUSLY! I know it's not the end of the road for some of those kicked off though after all we've seen people make it big regardless. There is always that hope!!!!

On a non-musical basic though it must be so hard to be close to people and see them kicked off. You're happy you are staying but losing a friend must suck. I'm sure some people after all this time have connected. You see people crying and you think of how hard it is to be happy for yourself but sad for others. If I had one shot and lost it it'd kill me too.

(Reply) (Thread) (Link)

arabian on March 12th, 2010 02:40 am (UTC)

Lily made me want to punch her through my tv screen. I've never reacted that way before to an AI contestant. I'm so glad she's gone. It *almost* makes up for Katelyn getting booted.

(Reply) (Parent) (Thread) (Link)

chessarook on March 12th, 2010 02:51 am (UTC)

I wanted to punch Tyler so I know the feeling. LOL. We both got our wishes!

(Reply) (Parent) (Thread) (Link)

eolivet on March 12th, 2010 03:41 am (UTC)

(Ooh, pretty icon!!! :)

I sincerely hope there are people who liked Lilly, and they all band together to vote Katie's bratty, entitled, pageanty, crocodile tear-stained self back to her giant mansion in Connecticut. :x Bah!! :p

I really liked Katelyn. :(

(Reply) (Thread) (Link)

weasleytook on March 12th, 2010 10:17 pm (UTC)

Ah, here is where we part ways, pal. I cannot find ANY reason to like Tim or why he should be in the top 12. (Much less the top 24.) SO BLAND.

I honestly am not even sure I care to watch now that both Katelyn and Alex have been knocked out because they both had tons of potential. And now that America is going to inflict BOTH Katie and Paige on my ears for another week? Blah. It's already a struggle for me to watch because of Tuesday night classes, so I may just watch Crystal's performance online and not even bother with the rest of it. It's kind of a given that she's going to win, which great for her, but boring as hell for the rest of us. Worst Top 24 ever and worst top 12 to go with it, IMO. :( I'm so disappointed.

(Reply) (Thread) (Link)

arabian on March 12th, 2010 11:03 pm (UTC)

Something about Tim just touches me, don't know why.

As for "worst top 12," honestly I think most of them have sucked with crappy singers who shouldn't have even been in the final fifty. I always just like one or two, and I'm quite happy with liking those one or two, so it's fine for me.

I am still pissed about Katelyn, makes no friggin' sense. As for Crystal definitely winning, I know it looks that way ... but Melinda was a given to win. She didn't. Archie was was a given to win. He didn't. Adam was was a given to win. He didn't. Except for Melinda, someone came out of the mid-ranks to win over people and take the top spot, so you never know with Idol.

(Reply) (Parent) (Thread) (Link)

Log in