Log in

No account? Create an account
20 February 2008 @ 09:59 am
And they cut Josiah!?!?!??!?  
Comments for last night's AI.

I was quite appalled with what I saw last night on AI. After almost every performance, I thought -- and Josiah isn't here?!??!!? I know some didn't like him (especially by the end), but when Simon was talking about being "relevant" in today's music over and over, I about lost it. Josiah was THE most relevant in today's music singer this show has EVER HAD!!!!!!! and they frickin' cut him!?!??!

I just didn't care about any performance. Okay, that's not true. I liked Danny Noriega's swagger and attitude. I like Michael Johns, but dude, he was totally channeling Jim Morrison and failing. David Hernandez bores me ridiculously and that last note was BAAAD. David Archuleta was so nervous, it affected his performance. Everyone else was either bad, boring or both.

Ugh. What an awful night to begin the semi's with. And, dangit, I felt Josiah's absence!
eolivet on February 20th, 2008 03:25 pm (UTC)
Again, I really think the reason they cut Josiah is because of the Sanjaya Effect. He seemed so fragile...I was afraid for him sometimes. :/

One thing for sure, Kyle the faux-geek could've put on a better show than Colton Culkin or David Hernandez. :x

This is why Simon should decide all contestants, and Randy and Paula are, at times, a waste of space.
Arabianarabian on February 20th, 2008 03:36 pm (UTC)
You could be right about it being the Sanjaya effect. After all, he was really good in the auditions. Josiah did seem quite fragile, I'll grant you that. Sigh.

Oh, Kyle would have been delghtful. Colton Culkin, long-haired 70's looking-Leif Garrett dude and David Hernandez were just embarrassing. BAD!

Honestly, I fastforward through Randy and Pauls's comments and just get to Simon's.